HOA Noise Lawsuit: $60,000 in Fees and Costs

Summary

A homeowner’s air-conditioning noise complaint became a lawsuit against neighbors and an HOA. The association was awarded $60,000 in attorney’s fees and costs, and the prevailing neighbors were also entitled to reasonable fees under the CC&Rs.

Noise and nuisance case decision

When an air-conditioner noise complaint becomes a fee dispute

One noise complaint led to a three-day trial, a $60,000 award of attorney’s fees and costs to the association, and a ruling entitling the prevailing neighbors to reasonable fees too. The case shows why the words in an HOA’s CC&Rs matter before a dispute reaches court.

Watch the 48-second case video

The $60,000 Hum

Linda and Frank’s fictional A/C dispute introduces the real court decision. Watch the video, then see what the court decided and what to check before a noise complaint becomes a lawsuit.

Open the video on HOA Member Services

Dramatization. Linda and Frank are fictional characters, not the parties in Burkett v. Dryja.

What happened

A homeowner said noise and vibration from her neighbors’ replacement air-conditioning unit reached her bedroom. The association investigated, found the unit properly installed and not objectionably loud, and declined enforcement. The homeowner sued both the neighbors and the association under the community’s CC&Rs.

The trial result: The court found the sound annoying but not an actionable nuisance or a violation of the governing documents.

The association’s award: $60,000 in attorney’s fees and costs.

The neighbors’ fee ruling: The Arizona Supreme Court held that the prevailing neighbors were also entitled to reasonable fees under this declaration. The trial court must determine the amount.

Three steps before a noise dispute escalates

Homeowners: Read the exact noise restriction. Record when the sound occurs, how long it lasts, and where it is heard. Save correspondence, recordings, and information about the equipment.
Boards: Check the rule and the facts before deciding whether to enforce. Document the investigation, any approvals or inspections, and the reason for the decision.
Managers: Preserve the complaint and supporting records. Bring questions about the meaning of the CC&Rs or enforcement to the board or other authorized decision-maker.

Before filing suit, read the attorney-fee clause too. Ask who can enforce the restrictions, who can recover fees, and whether costs are included. A claim described as a nuisance may also seek to enforce a contractual promise in the CC&Rs. This ruling applies to the particular declaration and Arizona law; another community or state may reach a different result.

A practical companion to this case

Put the right questions on paper

The HOA Noise & Nuisance Disputes Workbook gives homeowners, board members, and managers a way to work through a complaint before it becomes a legal fight. The 24-page fillable PDF walks through eight questions, from documenting the condition and checking the rule to weighing options and recording follow-up.

It includes worksheets, a dated event tracker, and a written-message planning tool. It helps organize a record; it does not decide whether a violation occurred.

HOA Noise and Nuisance Disputes workbook cover

Explore the fillable workbook

Why read the full case analysis?

The fee ruling turned on a point that is easy to miss: these CC&Rs gave individual owners enforcement rights against one another, even though nuisance law addressed the same conduct. The member article explains the court’s reasoning, the different fee decisions for the association and neighbors, and what each role should document before litigation.

See membership options Already a member? Sign in.

Subscription Required to Continue Reading

To view the full HOA Featured Article, you must have a Subscription with HOA Member Services

Become a Member

Personal Monthly

$

12.70

/month

Personal

$

97

Annual

Pro

$

297

Annual

HOA Team

$

347

Annual
Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top

Get Your FREE HOA Living Guide

Get ready to level up your community! Dive into our guide for homeowners and management personnel in neighborhoods run by homeowners associations. Download now for essential tips and exclusive resources— improve your community with one click!